Won’t Get Fooled Again?

I was already 10 minutes into my weekly prison class when a white woman stormed in in a huff, muttering so we all could hear that she was supposed to be released that morning but the court had apparently fucked up her paperwork. She got a little bit too close to me as she walked past and it was the first time I felt the slightest bit unnerved by an inmate.

“What are we supposed to be doing?” she asked, somewhat resigned that she wasn’t in fact, at least for the time being, going anywhere. The other women filled her in and continued doing what they had been asked to do.

As per usual (and I’m going to switch this up a bit going forward), the women are asked to tell us about something we’d be surprised to know about them—something that would dispel the way people sized them up as “junkies,” “losers,” and bad mothers.

This woman was eager to share:

“I was a professional model and did runway shows for really famous designers in the 90s. I was Miss Teen USA in (the late 80s) and we didn’t know that the judges were all professional model scouts. I got signed to Elite the next week.”

“REALLY?” I practically squealed. “Who did you do runway for?”

“I did Versace. The best thing about him was that he always let you have one piece of his clothes. Christy Turlington stole a pair of my leather pants. “

I gasped.

“Yep, she’s a thief.”

“Oh my God! She’s my favorite!” I said in disbelief. CHRISTY, yoga guru, peace activist, holistic skincare creator? Say it ain’t so.

She went on to say that she and some other big-named supermodels of the time started a support group for young models to keep them away from the cocaine that was all- too available to them by the industry to help keep them thin.

I realized by looking around at the rest of the women that this side conversation was a bit lost on them and was taking up way too much of their time.

She went on to say that she was held hostage for 4 years by a human trafficking ring and once released she helped to form an “underground railroad” for Asian girls to help them escape the sex trade.

At this point the other women were amazed, awed by the things she had done to help others. When, at the end of class, she handed me her paper, she wrote that she had published poetry and had some pieces of art shown at some very reputable Boston galleries. She wrote her name at the top so that I could Google her to see her Miss Teen USA photos and whatever other modeling shots I could find of her. I was excited to see what she might have looked like before she became a self-admitted drug addict, with unwashed hair, bad skin and a prison uniform.

After class I ran up to the woman who runs the program and asked, maybe too excitedly, if she knew that the woman was a RUNWAY model in the 90s?! I told her that she had written down her name so I could look her up online. The program director pulled me by the hand and said, “We’re doing this now.”

We went into her office and used every search term we could use to find her. Nothing.

“She totally lied to you,” she said, understanding my disappointment. “These women are some of the most manipulative women I’ve ever known. They have to be to live on the streets and do what they do to make money to support their habits and lifestyle.”

“When I get home I’m going to keep searching,” I said. I SO wanted this to be true to prove that someone could not randomly pick something so specific, giving me what was purported to be her professional name so that I could see her in all of her glory. Was she feeding into whatever I may have been putting out there in my excitement? Did the vapid starfucker in me come out?

Truth be told, she didn’t have the features that models have. She was only 5’10’’ a teeny bit shorter than most runway models. I searched obsessively for her for over an hour. I found the list of Miss Teen USA contestants and winners since its beginning and her name wasn’t among them. I combined every possible first name, middle name and last name that she gave me with “model”, “Versace,” “Elite,” and the only thing that came up was a woman who was burned at the stake in 1620 for being a witch.

Something very similar happened to me at my first job with a disenfranchised population: Without any training, I answered phones at the largest AIDS organization in New England for newly diagnosed people with HIV and AIDS. Even though the majority of the clients we served were gay men, it was just seeping into the addict population. One day I picked up a call and a woman had me in tears with an incredible and seemingly genuine sob story about stolen money, eviction, lack of food and medication. I told her to come to our offices immediately so I could get her the frozen food we had on hand and some free legal and housing advice. When I told my co-workers her name, they just laughed and told me that she was an addict and made these types of calls weekly to take whatever it was we would give her. I had been played.

I know people who get caught up in their own lies, who like the inmate above has probably convinced herself that she had done all the things she claimed. Was that her purpose, to make her feel worthy? Was she trying to impress me and the other inmates? Why was it so important to me that the things she claimed were true? I don’t want to be hardened to these women. I want to take what they choose to share at face value. I’m not sure I have the instincts to know what is true but I fear that if I start looking at what I’m doing with skepticism it could take away from an experience that has changed my life.



  1. people like this are the ones that can make the rest of us jaded. don't let her take away your "innocence," your ability to take these women at face value. the next woman you interact with may be totally changed by her interaction with you, and it would be a disservice to you both if it were colored by the lies of the "model." you weren't taken, and she didn't look at you that way. she just got to share her "story," and i doubt that she sat back and laughed because she got one by you. that's not why she does it. when someone has a story with that much detail, he or she believes it, they've told it so much. please don't hold them all hostage to one liar by becoming a skeptic. 🙂

  2. Really well said, Linda. I might add that this reminds me of how wives feel when their husbands cheat. Often, instead of being angry with HIM, they are angry at themselves and feel foolish for being "had". The blames shouldn't fall on the victim, but on the liar. If you are a sympathetic person with an open heart, hopefully you can get through life holding onto it. If you change, you not only shortchange yourself and those you meet, but have also declared the liars of the world the winners.

  3. Dan

    This comment has been removed by the author.

  4. Dan

    If your intent with this group is to develop them as writers, then I'd say you found a winner. Good (fiction) writers are invariably skilled liars. Don't think of yourself as "fooled;" rather, think of yourself as a great audience. And that's a wonderful thing for a writing teacher to be!

  5. Lew

    When I was 16, my dad took me to the DMV in Garden City, Long Island for my learner's permit. While milling around for the obligatory hours of waiting, we were approached by a young man who needed to borrow $20 for….something. I don't remember what, actually, just that I believed his story 100%. After all, he was an Eagle Scout, showed us ID, and gave us a phone number. He took down my dad's address and solemnly swore to pay back the money promptly. My dad, always the nicest, most generous man on the planet, handed over the $20, and then carefully explained to me that this was an act of charity and we would never be paid back. I told him that he was wrong. I had looked into the man's eyes and saw something genuine there. Of course, my dad was right. Since then, it seems like I get approached once a month by someone who has run out of gas, yet turns down my offer of a ride to a gas station where I would be happy to fill up a gas can for them and then take them to their car. Often the story involves a sick child and a mean boss. Sometimes I resent the dance. I'm hardly naive at this stage in my life, and I have to swallow my pride a bit to let someone think that I'm a sap. In the end,though, I think, "There but by the grace of God go I." I have been taught that we keep what we have only by giving it away.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s